Starclassic maple or DW collectors

Hi i would like your opinions, what do you think about those kits? are they comparable in sound and quality?
i have the chance to buy a 4pc (10,12,14,22) dw collectors from 2004 used in very good condition or a 4pc (10,12,16,22)tama starclassic maple new
the collectors it's much more expensive than the starclassic in this case
thanks

Starclassic maple or DW collectors